• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • US Open Cup Central
  • US Open Cup Qualifying
  • US Open Cup History
  • Amateur Cup

Complete U.S. Open Cup Coverage

  • 2026 USOC Schedule
  • 2026 USOC Stat Leaders
  • 2027 USOC Qualifying Results
  • TheCup.us Awards
  • Join TheCup.us Patreon!
  • Contact Us

Brookhattan

US Soccer legend Walter Bahr leaves behind Hall of Fame legacy

June 28, 2018 by Chuck Nolan Jr.

Philadelphia Inquirer, 1953
Philadelphia Inquirer, 1953

On June 18, American Soccer lost one of its legendary figures when Walter Bahr passed away in Boalsburg, Pa. from complications related to a broken hip. He was 91.

Bahr’s most famous moment came during the 1950 World Cup when he provided the assist on Joe Gaetjens’ goal that led the United States3 to one of the biggest upsets in World Cup history when they defeated England. Bahr made 19 appearances for the United States national team, and also appeared in the 1948 Olympics for the U.S. While Bahr was perhaps more noted for his Olympic and National team appearances, his US Open Cup and American Soccer League (ASL) pedigree is just as impressive which is why his induction into the National Soccer Hall of Fame was such an easy decision.

Bahr led Northeast High School to an undefeated season and a Public League championship in 1943 which got the attention of the Philadelphia Nationals of the American Soccer League. At the age of 17, he signed with the Nationals and also played three seasons of college soccer at Temple University where he was an All-American.

Bahr made his US Open Cup debut on March 25, 1945 at the age of 18 in the Philadelphia Nationals’ 6-1 win over Hosiery Local, an amateur club from Philadelphia. Once Walter became a regular in the Nationals’ lineup, their Open Cup success grew. Bahr made two appearances in Open Cup Finals with the Nationals in 1949 and 1952.

In the first leg of the 1949 Final, Bahr assisted on Nick Kropfelder’s 35th minute goal in the Nationals’ 1-0 win over Morgan Strasser of Pittsburgh. Unfortunately, Bahr would not lift the trophy that year as Morgan Strasser rebounded with a 4-2 second leg win and won the title 4-3 on aggregate. In 1952, Bahr started both legs of the Final for the Nationals, helping Philadelphia take a 4-3 lead into the second leg back home. Again Bahr and the Nationals would fall short as the Harmarville Hurricanes won 2-1 to force extra time and score two goals to lift the trophy 7-5 on aggregate.

In 1950 and 1951, the club reached the Eastern Final (National Semifinals) and they made it to the Quarterfinals in 1953.

While with the Nationals, Bahr helped the club win four ASL championships in five seasons, from 1949-1951 and again in 1953.

After the Nationals folded after four games in 1953-54 season, Bahr moved to New York to play for Brookhattan. The Brooklyn club fell one point shy of the ASL title, and were eliminated from the Open Cup in the First Round that year.

The following year, Bahr returned to Philadelphia to join the Nationals’ old cross-town rivals, Uhrik Truckers, who were formerly named the Philadelphia Americans. Bahr continued his success picked up his Open Cup success where he left off the last time he was in Philly, reaching the Eastern Final in 1955 (vs. Eintracht of the German American Soccer League) and the Quarterfinals in 1956 (vs. Harmarville of Western Pennsylvania). Both times the Truckers lost to the eventual Open Cup champions.

Philadelphia Inquirer, Dec. 2 1943
Philadelphia Inquirer, Dec. 2 1943

The Truckers luck ran out in 1958, losing to the amateur Ukrainian American SC in the preliminary rounds. Bahr rounded out his ASL title count at six, winning two more with the Truckers in 1955 and 1956. Bahr went back to New York for a brief spell to play for Eintracht SC of the German American Soccer League before putting an end to his professional playing career to turn to coaching.

During Bahr’s time playing in Philadelphia he began coaching at Frankfort High School, a position he held for 15 years before moving on to take charge of the Swarthmore College freshman team. In August of 1963 was has brought on as the manager of the Ukrainian Nationals, and after a few successful years with the Ukes, Bahr moved on to the ASL’s Philadelphia Spartans in 1969.

After one season, he switched to coach his alma mater at Temple where he was in charge of the Owls program from 1971-74. He left North Broad Street for Happy Valley where he was hired as the head coach at Penn State and remained there for 14 years. During his time in charge of the Nittany Lions, he led the program to 12 NCAA tournament appearances and was named the NSCAA National Coach of the Year after leading Penn State to the National Semifinals in 1979.

Bahr, along with the entire 1950 World Cup team, was inducted into the National Soccer Hall of Fame in 1976. At the time of his death, he was the last surviving member of that historic team.

Bahr had three sons and a daughter. Chris and Matt played under their father at Penn State, while Casey attended Navy during the late 1960s, and all three played in the North American Soccer League for brief periods. Casey and Chris were also part of the United German Hungarian team that reached the 1977 US Open Cup Final against Maccabee AC of Los Angeles. Remarkably, Chris was playing for UGH during the summer in 1977 while also a kicker for the NFL’s Cincinnati Bengals. Matt and Chris both had long and successful NFL careers, each playing on Super Bowl winning teams twice. His daughter Davies Ann Desiderio was also an elite athlete as she was an all-american gymnast at Penn State.

Filed Under: Feature - History, Feature - Main, US Open Cup, US Open Cup History Tagged With: Brookhattan, Eintracht SC, Philadelphia Americans, Philadelphia Nationals, Philadelphia Spartans, Uhrik Truckers, Ukrainian Nationals, United German Hungarians, Walter Bahr

1945 National Challenge Cup Results

January 11, 2009 by Josh Hakala

Round of 32
Eastern Bracket
5/14/45 Brookhattan 3 : 1 (aet) New York Americans
3/18/45 Brooklyn Hispano 2 : 0 German American AC
3/11/45 Brooklyn Wanderers 4 : 3 Eintracht SC (NYC)
5/14/45 Kearny Irish 2 : 1 Kearny Scots
4/1/45 Baltimore Americans 4 : 0 Ruggiero SC (Bal.)
3/4/45 Baltimore SC 11 : 0 Phoenix SC (Phi.)

Philadelphia Americans

Philadelphia Nationals
Western Bracket
4/1/45 Slovak SC (Chi.) 1 : 0 Sparta (Chi.)
4/1/45 Viking AA (Chi.) 2 : 1 Hakoah Center (Chi.)
3/11/45 Cleveland Americans 11 : 2 Rochester Celtics
5/2/45 Gallatin (W. Pa.) 3 : 0 Morgan Strasser (W. Pa.)

United German Americans (Det.)

???
4/1/45
Raftery Painters (St. L) 5 : 3
National Slug (St. L)

Croatian Eagles (Mil.) bye Only Wisconsin Entry


Round of 16
Eastern Bracket
5/20/45 Brookhattan 2 : 1 Kearny Irish
5/13/45 Brooklyn Hispano 4 : 3 (aet) Brooklyn Wanderers
5/13/45 Philadelphia Americans 3 : 2 Philadelphia Nationals
4/8/45 Baltimore Americans 1 : 0 Baltimore SC

Western Bracket
4/29/45 Viking AA 4 : 2 (aet) Slovak SC
5/6/45 Raftery Painters 4 : 1 Croatian Eagles

United German Americans
5/13/45 Cleveland Americans 2 : 1 (aet) Gallatin


Quarterfinals
5/25/45 Brooklyn Hispano 4 : 3 Philadelphia Americans
5/25/45 Brookhattan 3 : 2 Baltimore Americans
5/27/45 Viking A.A. 3 : 6
Raftery Painters
5/27/45 United German Americans 1 : 2 Cleveland Americans
Semifinals
6/4/45 Brookhattan 5 : 4(aet) Brooklyn Hispano
6/3/45 Raftery Painters 0 : 2 Cleveland Americans
Final
First Leg – Starlight Park – Bronx, New York
6/10/45 Brookhattan 4 : 1 Cleveland Americans
Second Leg -at  Shaw Field – Cleveland, Ohio
6/16/45 Cleveland Americans 1 : 2 Brookhattan
Brookhattan win National Challenge Cup on 6-2 aggregate
KEY – w/o – Walkover, R – Replay, 1L – 1st Leg, 2L – 2nd Leg, 3L – 3rd Leg

Filed Under: US Open Cup Tagged With: 1945, Baltimore Americans, Brookhattan, Brooklyn Hispano, Cleveland Americans, Philadelphia Americans, Shaw Field, Starlight Park, United German Americans, Viking AA

1940 National Challenge Cup Results

January 10, 2009 by Josh Hakala

First Round
Eastern Bracket
11/5/39 Lusitania Recreation 3 : 1 Ludlow Lusitano
11/5/39 St. Michaels (Mass.) 2 : 0* Newark Portuguese
*Match abandoned after 35 minutes due to heavy rain
11/12/39 R St. Michaels 2 : 1 Newark Portuguese
11/12/39 Baltimore SC 10 : 1 St. Gerard (Bal.)
11/12/39 German American SC (Phi.) 4 : 0 German SC (Reading)
11/12/39 New York Americans 3 : 0 German Hungarian SC
11/12/39 Swedish FC (NYC) 2 : 1 Haitkvoh (NYC)
11/12/39 Kearny Scots 9 : 0 Allentown SC
11/12/39 St. Mary’s Celtic (Brooklyn) 2 : 0 Brooklyn Hispano
11/12/39 Gjoa SC (NYC) 3 : 1 German S.C. (Brooklyn)
11/12/39 Norwegian American SC (NYC) 2 : 1 Kollsman (NYC)
11/18/39 Holy Cross 0 : 2 Pawtucket FC
11/19/39 Brookhattan 3 : 0 Galicia (NYC)
11/19/39 Firestone FC (Mass.) W : L Baylies (Mass.)
11/19/39 Paterson SC (NJ) 4 : 0 Kearny Irish
11/19/39 Passon SC (Phi.) 1 : 0 German SC (Phi.)
11/19/39 Baltimore Americans 2 : 4 (aet) Kensington Blue Bells (Phi.)
Western Bracket
11/5/39 Viking A.A. (Chi.) 1 : 1 Swedish American SC (Chi.)
11/12/39 R Viking A.A. 1 : 3 Swedish American SC
11/5/39 Sparta Fallstaff (Chi.) 4 : 0 Olympia SC (Chi.)
11/5/39 Shamrocks SC (Cle.) 3 : 1 Dalarda SC (Cle.)
11/12/39 Bartunek Clothes (Cle.) 7 : 2 Dunlevy (W. Pa.)
11/5/39 Hungarian Sports Club (Mil.) 3 : 3 Schlitz (Mil.)
11/12/39 R Hungarian Sports Club 5 : 4 Schlitz
11/5/39 Morgan Sport Club (W. Pa.) 1 : 0 Cuddy (W. Pa.)
11/5/39 Harmarville (W. Pa.) 1 : 6 Heidelberg (W. Pa.)
11/5/39 Glendale (W. Pa.) 3 : 0 Muse (W. Pa.)
11/5/39 Canonsburg (W. Pa.) 2 : 0 Gallatin (W. Pa.)
11/5/39 Curry (W. Pa.) 2 : 4 Castle Shannon (W. Pa.)
11/5/39 Buffalo City Hungarian SC 3 : 1 MacKenzie SC (Niagra Falls)
11/5/39 Becks German American SC (Buf.) 9 : 5 (aet) German AC (Roch.)

Manhattan Beer (Chi.) bye

Chrysler SC (Det.) bye

Celtic SC (Det.) bye

Thistles SC (Roch.) bye


Second Round
Eastern Bracket
12/3/39 Brookhattan 2 : 1 Swedish FC
12/3/39 Kearny Scots 3 : 2 Paterson SC
12/4/39 Baltimore SC 5 : 1 Kensington Blue Bells
12/10/39 New York Americans 1 : 0 Gjoa SC
12/10/39 German American SC 2 : 2 Passon SC
12/16/39 R German American SC 4 : 2 (aet) Passon SC
12/3/39 Lusitania Recreation 4 : 1 Pawtucket FC
12/4/39 St. Mary’s Celtic 1 : 0 Norwegian American SC
12/10/39 Firestone FC 3 : 0 St. Michaels


Western Bracket
12/3/39 Sparta Fallstaff 2 : 0 Manhattan Beer
12/3/39 Swedish American SC 7 : 0 Hungarian Sports Club
12/3/39 Thistles SC 1 : 6 Canonsburg
12/3/39 Heidelberg 2 : 1 Castle Shannon
12/10/39 Morgan Sport Club 3 : 3 (aet) Glendale
12/17/39 R Morgan Sport Club 0 : 0(aet) Glendale
12/25/39 R Morgan Sport Club 2 : 0* Glendale
*Match abandoned at 70th minute due to crowd trouble
12/31/39 R Morgan Sport Club 5 : 0 Glendale
12/10/39 Buffalo Becks 4 : 2 Buffalo City Hungarian SC
12/10/39 Chrysler SC 3 : 1 Celtic SC
12/24/39 Bartunek Slavia 0 : 2 Shamrocks SC


Third Round
Eastern Bracket
1/1/40 German American SC 1 : 4 Baltimore SC
1/1/40 Kearny Scots 3 : 4(aet) St. Mary’s Celtic
1/1/40 Brookhattan 1 : 1 New York Americans
1/21/40 R Brookhattan 1 : 0 New York Americans
1/1/40 Lusitania Recreation 2 : 2 Firestone FC
1/6/40 R Lusitania Recreation 5 : 2 Firestone FC
Western Bracket
12/17/39 Sparta Falstaff 2 : 0 Swedish American SC
12/24/39 Chrysler SC 3 : 0 Shamrocks SC
1/14/40 Morgan Sport Club 8 : 1 Buffalo Becks
1/1/40 Heidelberg W : L Cannonsburg


Quarterfinals
3/17/40 St. Mary’s Celtic 2 : 3 Baltimore SC
3/17/40 Lusitania Recreation 2 : 2 Brookhattan
3/17/40 Sparta Fallstaff 1 : 0 Chrysler SC
3/17/40 Morgan Sport Club 2 : 0 Heidelburg SC


Semifinals
4/13/40 1L Baltimore SC 3 : 1 Brookhattan
4/15/40 2L Brookhattan 2 : 2 Baltimore SC
Baltimore SC advance on 5-3 aggregate
4/7/40 1L Spatra Fallstaff 1 : 1 Morgan Sport Club
4/14/40 2L Morgan Sport Club 1 : 1 (aet) Sparta Fallstaff
4/21/40 R Sparta Fallstaff 1 : 0 Morgan Sport Club
Sparta Fallstaff advance on 3-2 aggregate


Final
First Leg – at Bugle Field – Baltimore, Maryland
5/5/40 Baltimore SC 0 : 0 Sparta Fallstaff
Second Leg – at Sparta Stadium – Chicago, Illinois
5/12/40 Sparta Fallstaff 2 : 2(aet) Baltimore SC
Aggregate drawn 2-2, Championship shared when details for a third game could not be agreed upon
KEY – w/o – Walkover, R – Replay, 1L – 1st Leg, 2L – 2nd Leg, 3L – 3rd Leg

Filed Under: US Open Cup Tagged With: 1940, Baltimore SC, Brookhattan, Bugle Field, Chrysler SC, Heidelberg SC, Lusitania Recreation, Morgan Sport Club, Sparta Fallstaff, Sparta Stadium, St. Mary's Celtic

1939 National Challenge Cup Results

January 10, 2009 by Josh Hakala

Round of 32
Eastern Bracket
1/9/39 Baltimore SC 4 : 0 Brooklyn Hakoah
1/9/39 Brooklyn Hispano 1 : 2 Holy Cross (Fall River)
1/9/39 Brookhattan (NYC) 4 : 1 Bethlehem Hungarian SC
1/9/39 German American SC (Phi.) 2 : 1 Baltimore German SC
1/9/39 Trenton Highlanders 2 : 0 Kearny Irish
1/29/39 New York Americans 1 : 3 St. Mary’s Celtic (Brooklyn)
2/5/39 Passon SC (Phi.) 3 : 3 Kearny Scots
2/10/39 R Kearny Scots 3 : 2 Passon SC (Phi.)
1/8/39
Lusitania Recreation 4 : 3
St. Michael’s
1/22/39 Lusitania Recreation 1 : 0 St. Michael’s


Western Bracket
12/11/38 Sparta Garden City (Chi.) 1 : 0 Olympia SC (Chi.)
12/11/38 Manahttan Beer (Chi.) 4 : 0 Swedish American SC (Chi.)
12/11/38 German Sport Club (W. Pa.) 3 : 0 Curry (W. Pa)
12/11/38 Morgan Sports Club (Pit.) 2 : 1 Heidelberg (W. Pa.)
12/11/378 Shamrock SC (Cle.) 2 : 2 Bartunek Slavia (Cle.)
12/18/38 R Shamrock SC 0 : 0 (aet) Bartunek Slavia
1/2/39 R Shamrock SC 1 : 5 Bartunek Slavia

Kodak Park (Roch.)
12/11/38
Lindell Trust (St. L) 3 : 1
Burke(St. L)

Chrysler SC (Det.)


Round of 16
Eastern Bracket
2/12/39 German American SC 1 : 0 Baltimore SC
2/12/39 St. Mary’s Celtic 6 : 4 (aet) Trenton Highlanders
3/19/39 Brookhattan 1 : 0 Kearny Scots
2/12/39
Lusitania Recreation 1 : 1
Holy Cross
2/19/39
Lusitania Recreation 2 : 1
Holy Cross
Western Bracket
1/8/39 Sparta Garden City 7 : 1 Lindell Trust
1/8/39 Manhattan Beer 4 : 2 Chrysler SC
1/8/39 German Sport Club 1 : 1 (aet) Morgan Sport Club
1/15/39
R Morgan Sport Club 5 : 0 German Sport Club
1/8/39 Kodak Park 1 : 1 (aet) Bartunek Slavia
1/15/39 R Bartunek Slavia 3 : 0 Kodak Park


Quarterfinals
3/12/39 Manhattan Beer 3 : 2 Bartunek Slavia
3/12/39 Morgan Sport Club 4 : 2 Sparta A & BA
3/26/39 German American SC 3 : 2 (aet) Lusitania Recreation
4/2/39 Brookhattan 1 : 3 St. Mary’s Celtic


Semifinals
4/15/39 1L German American SC 0 : 2 St. Mary’s Celtic
4/16/39 2L St. Mary’s Celtic 1 : 2 German American SC
St. Mary’s Celtic advance on 3-2 aggregate
4/2/39 1L Morgan Sport Club 3 : 2 Manhattan Beer
4/19/39 2L Manhattan Beer 3 : 1 Morgan Sport Club
Manhattan Beer advance on 5-4 aggregate
Final
First Leg – at Sparta Stadium – Chicago, Illinois
4/30/39 Manhattan Beer 0 : 1 St. Mary’s Celtic
Second Leg – Starlight Park – Bronx, New York
5/7/39 St. Mary’s Celtic 4 : 1 Manhattan Beer
St. Mary’s Celtic win National Challenge Cup on 5-2 aggregate
KEY – w/o – Walkover, R – Replay, 1L – 1st Leg, 2L – 2nd Leg, 3L – 3rd Leg

Filed Under: US Open Cup Tagged With: 1939, Bartunek Slavia, Brookhattan, German American SC, Lusitania Recreation, Manhattan beer, Sparta A & BA, Sparta Stadium, St. Mary's Celtic, Starlight Park

1938 National Challenge Cup Results

January 10, 2009 by Josh Hakala

First Round
Eastern Bracket
1/16/38 Kearny Irish 3 : 5 Bethlehem Hungarian
1/16/38 New York Americans 4 : 2 Brooklyn First Germans
1/16/38 Brooklyn Hispano 1 : 1 (aet) St. Mary’s Celtic (Brooklyn)
1/22/38 R St. Mary’s Celtic 4 : 1 Brooklyn Hispano
1/16/38 Paterson Caledonians 1: 0 Kearny Scots
1/16/38 Baltimore SC 2 : 1 Budd AA (Phi.)
1/16/38 German American SC (Phi.) 3 : 3 Passon SC (Phi.)
1/23/38 R German American SC 2 : 0 Passon SC
1/23/38 Brookhattan (NYC) 4 : 1 Hatikvoh (NYC)
1/30/38 Lusitania Recriation 3 : 3 Ponta Delgada
Western Bracket
1/16/38 Maccabee SC (Chi.) 2 : 0 (aet) American Nickeloid (Peru, IL)
1/16/38 Schlitz (Mil.) 6 : 4 Racine Deutscher (WI)
1/16/38 Castle Shannon (W. Pa.) 2 : 0 Heidelberg (W. Pa.)
1/16/38 South Side Radio (St. L) 3 : 2 St. Patricks (St. L)
1/16/38 Sparta Garden City (Chi.) w/o Shamrocks SC (St. L)
1/23/38 Bartunek Slavia (Cle.) 3 : 1 Cecil Merchants (W. Pa.)
1/30/38 Burke Undertakers (St. L) 5 : 4 St. Matthews (St. L)
2/13/38 Thistles SC (Det.) 5 : 1 Eckert & Becker (Det.)
   
Second Round
Eastern Bracket
1/30/38 New York Americans 4 : 1 Bethlehem Hungarian
1/30/38 St. Mary’s Celtic 7 : 1 Baltimore SC
1/30/38 German American SC 5 : 3 Paterson Caledonian
2/20/38 Brookhattan 7 : 0 Ponta Delgada
Western Bracket
1/30/38 Maccabee SC 2 : 1 Schlitz
1/30/39 Castle Shannon 3 : 0 Bartunek Slavia
2/6/38 South Side Radio 1 : 0 Burke Undertakers
2/20/38 Sparta Garden City 5 : 0 Thistles SC
   
Quarterfinals
2/20/38 Castle Shannon 4 : 2 South Side Radio
2/27/38 New York Americans 4 : 3 Brookhattan
2/27/38 St. Mary’s Celtic 1 : 1 (aet) German American SC
3/5/38 R St. Mary’s Celtic 1 : 0 German American SC
2/27/38 Sparta Garden City 1 : 0 Maccabee SC
   
Semifinals
3/27/38 1L New York Americans 2 : 1 St. Mary’s Celtic
4/2/38 2L St. Mary’s Celtic 3 : 0 New York Americans
St. Mary’s Celtic advance on 4-2 aggregate
3/13/38 1L Castle Shannon 1 : 2 Sparta Garden City
3/20/38 2L Sparta Garden City 3 : 1 Castle Shannon
Sparta Garden City advance on 5-2 aggregate
   
Final
First Leg – at Sparta Stadium – Chicago, Illinois
4/17/38 Sparta Garden City 3 : 0 St. Mary’s Celtic
Second Leg – at  Starlight Park – Bronx, New York
4/24/38 St. Mary’s Celtic 2 : 3 Sparta Garden City
Sparta Garden City win National Challenge Cup on 6-2 aggregate
KEY – w/o – Walkover, R – Replay, 1L – 1st Leg, 2L – 2nd Leg, 3L – 3rd Leg

Filed Under: US Open Cup Tagged With: 1938, Brookhattan, Castle Shannon, German American SC, Maccabee AC, New York Americans, South Side Radio, Sparta Garden City, Sparta Stadium, St. Mary's Celtic, Starlight Park

1936 National Challenge Cup Results

January 10, 2009 by Josh Hakala

First Round
Eastern Bracket
2/2/36 Hatikvoh (NYC) 1 : 2 German Hungarian SC (NYC)
2/2/36 Kearny Irish 2 : 1 Newark Germans
2/15/36 Canton FC (Bal.) 5 : 3 Stonewall SC (Bal.)
3/1/36 Kearny Scots 2 : 0 Trenton Highlanders
3/1/36 German American SC (Phi.) 5 : 0 Budd AA (Phi.)
3/1/36 Santo Christo (New Bedford, MA) 2 : 1 Liberal AC (Fall River)
3/1/36 Brookhattan (NYC) 3 : 3 Brooklyn Hispano
3/8/36 R Brooklyn Hispano 4 : 4 Brookhattan
3/15/36 R Brooklyn Hispano 1 : 2 Brookhattan
3/7/36 New York Americans 2 : 3 St. Mary’s Celtic (Brooklyn)
Western Bracket
1/19/36 Olympia SC (Chi.) 3 : 2 Maccabee SC (Chi.)
2/2/36 Heidelberg (W. Pa.) 4 : 0 Curry Silver Tops (W. Pa.)
1/19/36 Shamrocks SC (St. L) 0 : 0 Hellrung Grimm (St. L)
2/2/36 R Shamrocks SC 6 : 1 Hellrung Grimm
1/19/36 Bartunek Slavia (Cle.) 2 : 1 Highland Park Chrysler (Det.)
1/12/36 Marres (St. L) 4 : 2 Burke Undertakers (St. L)
2/23/36 Sparta Garden City (Chi.) 6 : 0 Ben Miller SC (St. L)
3/8/36 Vienna AC (Mil.) 5 : 4 Bayern Schlitz (Mil.)
1/26/36 Rochester Celtics 0 : 4
Kodak Park (Roch.)


Second Round
Eastern Bracket
3/15/36 German American SC 3 : 2 Canton FC
3/22/36 Brookhattan 2 : 0 German Hungarian SC
3/22/36 St. Mary’s Celtic 4 : 1 Santo Christo
3/22/36 Kearny Scots 2 : 0 Kearny Irish
Western Bracket
2/23/36 Heidelberg 4 : 1 Kodak Park
3/1/36 Sparta Garden City 2 : 1 (aet) Olympia SC
3/1/36 Shamrocks SC 4 : 3 Bartunek Slavia
3/15/36 Marres 6 : 3 Vienna AC


Quarterfinals
3/22/36 Shamrocks SC 2 : 1 Marres
3/22/36 Sparta Garden City 1 : 2 Heidelburg
3/29/36 St. Mary’s Celtic 2 : 1 Brookhattan
4/5/36 Kearny Scots 0 : 1 German American SC
Semifinals


4/12/36 1L St. Mary’s Celtic 0 : 2 German American SC
4/19/36 2L German American SC 0 : 1 St. Mary’s Celtic
German American SC advance on 2-1 aggregate
3/29/36 1L Shamrocks SC 1 : 1 Heidelburg SC
4/5/36 2L Heidelburg SC 1 : 2 Shamrocks SC
Shamrocks SC advance on 3-2 aggregate


Final
First Leg – at Walsh Memorial Stadium – St. Louis, Missouri
4/26/36 Shamrocks SC 2 : 2 German American SC
Second Leg – Rifle Club Grounds – Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
5/3/36 German American SC 3 : 0 Shamrocks SC
German American SC win National Challenge Cup on 5-2 aggregate
KEY – w/o – Walkover, R – Replay, 1L – 1st Leg, 2L – 2nd Leg, 3L – 3rd Leg

Filed Under: US Open Cup Tagged With: 1936, Brookhattan, German American SC, Heidelberg, Kearny Scots, Marres, Rifle Club Grounds, Shamrocks SC, Sparta Garden City, St. Mary's Celtic, Walsh Memorial Stadium

Primary Sidebar

Follow Us on Social Media

  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

U.S. Open Cup History

1935 National Challenge Cup Semifinals: After 29 days, Central Breweries win 3-game Western Final

The Western Final of the 1934/1935 National Challenge Cup featured one of Chicago’s best teams from the first 30 years of the tournament against a St. Louis team that would form their own dynasty.

  • 1995 US Open Cup: Rob Ukrop of Richmond Kickers voted TheCup.us Player of the Tournament
  • 1995 US Open Cup Final: Jeff Causey of Richmond Kickers voted TheCup.us Player of Round
  • 1995 US Open Cup Final: Richmond Kickers survive heat, beat El Paso Patriots in PKs to win title
  • 1995 US Open Cup Final Preview: El Paso Patriots hosting amateur Richmond Kickers in “El Sauna”
  • 1995 US Open Cup Semifinals: Jake Arrambide of El Paso Patriots voted TheCup.us Player of Round

Analytics powered by

Copyright © 2026 • Built by Jacob Martella Web Development