• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • US Open Cup Central
  • US Open Cup Qualifying
  • US Open Cup History
  • Amateur Cup

Complete U.S. Open Cup Coverage

  • 2025 USOC Schedule
  • 2025 USOC Stat Leaders
  • 2025 USOC Qualifying Results
  • TheCup.us Awards
  • Join TheCup.us Patreon!
  • Contact Us

1920

1919-1920 National Challenge Cup Results

January 16, 2009 by Josh Hakala

1919/1920 National Challenge Cup champion Ben Miller SC
Ben Miller FC - 1920 National Challenge Cup champions
Ben Miller FC – 1920 National Challenge Cup champions

 

First Round
Southern New York
11/2/19 Robins Dry Dock 3 : 2 Morse Dry Dock
11/2/19 Interborough Rapid Transit 1 : 0 Longfellows FC
11/2/19 Greenpoint FC 1 : 2 New York FC
  Clan McDuff 0 : 1 Newburgh Shipyards
New Jersey
11/2/19 American FC 5 : 3 Victor AA
  Bunker Hill 1 : 3 Paterson FC
  Haledon Thistles 1 : 2 Babcock & Wilcox
11//19 Malta FC 7 : 2 Edison AFC
  Erie AA w/o West Hudson FC
Southern New England
  Crompton FC 4 : 1 J & P Coats
  New Bedford Celtics 0 : 0 St. Michael’s FC
  Fairlawn Rovers 2 : 3 Greystone Life Savers
Northern Massachusetts
11/2/19 Abbot Worsted 3 : 2 Lynn Hibernains
  United Shoe 6 : 1 Andover United
  General Electric 0 : 2 Fore River FC
11/1/19 Lynn Thistles * Lawrence League
  Boston City 0 : 2 Squantum
Connecticut
  Sons of St. George vs. Bridgeport Thistles
11/2/19 Bridgeport City 2 : 1 Bridgeport Rovers
Eastern Pennsylvania
11//19 J & J Dobson AA 8 : 1 Viscose FC
11//19 New York Ship 3 : 0 Sun Ship AFC
11/2/19 Merchants Ship 5 : 1 Germantown Boys
11/15/19 Bethlehem Steel 7 : 1 Puritan YML
11//19 Wolfenden Shore 2 : 4 Wanderers FC
Western Pennsylvania
  Madison FC 4 : 2 Beadling
  Cuddy FC vs. Pittsburgh Terminal
Ohio
11/2/19 Magyar American FC 6 : 1 Goodrich FC
11/2/19 Goodyear FC 2 : 1 (aet) White Motor
11//19 Firestone FC 0 : 1 Bricklayers
Illinois
11//19 Harvey FC 0 : 1 Thistle FC
11/3/19 Magyar FC 0 : 6 Palmer Park
11/3/19 Bricklayers FC 3 : 1 Rangers AC
   
Second Round
Southern New York & New Jersey
11/27/19 New York FC 1 : 0 Paterson FC
11/23/19 Babcock & Wilcox 2 : 1 Interborough Rapid Transit
  Newburgh Shipyards 4 : 2 American FC
  Malta AC 0 : 2 Tebo Yacht Basin
  Erie AA 8 : 1 West Side AFC
11/30/19 Federal Ship 2 : 3 Robins Dry Dock
Eastern Pennsylvania
11/29/19 Bethlehem Steel 3: 0 Merchant Ship
  Wanderers 3 : 1 Disston AA
11//19 New York Ship 2 : 2 J & J Dobson AA
Southern New England
  Fall River Rovers 4 : 1 Greystone Life Savers
  New Bedford Celtics 1 : 3 J & P Coats
Northern Massachusetts
11//19 Chicopee Rovers 0 : 1 Fore River FC
  Lynn Thistles vs. Squantum FC
  United Shoe 2 : 1 Abbot Worsted
Connecticut
  New Haven FC 3 : 1 Bridgeport Swedish AC
  Sons of St. George 2 : 4 Bridgeport City
Western Pennsylvania
  Pittsburgh Terminal Coal FC 5 : 2 Madison FC
  McKeesport National Tube w/o Cuddy AA
Northwestern New York
  Oneida Community 1 : 1 McNaughton Rangers
  Rochester City Moose 1 : 0 Rochester Celtics
Ohio
  Ideal Tire & Rubber 1 : 2 Goodyear FC
11/30/19 Bricklayers FC 3 : 1 Magyar American FC
Michigan
  Packard FC 3 : 1 Bricklayers FC
  Pontiac City FC 7 : 0 Vikings FC
  Rising Star FC 0 : 0 Detroit SFC
  Caledonia FC 4 : 0 Roses FC
Illinois
  Palmer Park 5 : 1 Thistles AFC
  Lake Forest FC 1 : 4 Lincoln Park FC
11/23/19 Olympia FC 5 : 1 Thistle FC
11/23/19 Bricklayers FC 1 : 0 Swedish American FC
Missouri
  Ben Miller FC 6 : 1 Innisfalls FC
  Scullin Steel 3 : 1 St. Louis Screw
   
Third Round
Eastern Bracket
12/24/19 Robins Dry Dock 3 : 1 Tebo Yacht Basin
12/29/19 New York FC 1 : 1* Erie AA
  *match stopped after 70 minutes due to broken crossbar, replay ordered
1/6/20 R New York FC 2 : 1 (aet) Erie AA
12/27/19 Bethlehem Steel 1 : 0 New York Ship
12/28/19 Fore River Rovers 3 : 1 J & P Coats
1/1/20 Babcock & Wilcox 0 : 1 Newburgh Shipyards
1/1/20 Lynn Thistles 0 : 2 Fall River Rovers
1/1/20 United Shoe 3 : 1 New Haven
1/5/20 Bridgeport City 0 : 4 Wanderers FC
Western Bracket
12/25/19 Rochester City Moose 3 : 1 McNaughton Rangers
1/4/20 Ben Miller FC 2 : 1 Scullin Steel
1/5/20 Packard FC 2 : 1 Rising Star FC
1/8/20 Bricklayers FC (Cle.) 1 : 3 Goodyear FC
1/8/20 Pittsburgh Terminal 1 : 2 McKeesport National Tube
3/20/20 Olympia FC 3 : 3 (aet) Palmer Park
3/31/20 R Olympia FC 3 : 1 Palmer Park
3/29/20 Pontiac City 0 : 8 Caledonia FC
  Bricklayers FC (Chi.) w/o Lincoln Park FC
   
Fourth Round
Eastern Bracket
3/20/20 Bethlehem Steel 10 : 0 Wanderers FC
3/22/20 Robins Dry Dock 4 : 0 Fall River Rovers
3/27/20 Fore River Rovers 3 : 0 United Shoe
3/28/20 New York FC 2 : 1 Newburg Shipyards
Western Bracket
2/6/20 Goodyear FC 1 : 2 Rochester City Moose
2/10/20 Ben Miller FC 3 : 2 McKeesport FC
3/28/20 Bricklayers & Masons 1 : 2 Olympia FC
  Packard FC 3 : 2 Caledonia FC
   
Quarterfinals
4/4/20 Robins Dry Dock 1 : 0 Bethlehem Steel
4/5/20 Ben Miller FC 2 : 1 Olympia FC
4/5/20 Fore River Rovers 3 : 0 New York FC
4/23/20 Packard FC 5 : 1 Rochester City Moose
   
Semifinals
4/10/20 Fore River Rovers 2 : 0 Robins Dry Dock
4/25/20 Ben Miller FC 4 : 2 Packard FC
   
Final
at Handlan’s Park, St. Louis, Missouri
5/8/20 Ben Miller FC 2 : 1 Fore River Rovers
KEY – w/o – Walkover, R – Replay

Filed Under: US Open Cup Tagged With: 1920, Ben Miller FC, Bethlehem Steel FC, Fore River Rovers, Handlans Park, National Challenge Cup, New York FC, Olympia FC, Packard FC, Robins Dry Dock, Rochester City Moose

Primary Sidebar

Follow Us on Social Media

  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

U.S. Open Cup History

Dating back to 1913, Philadelphia vs. Pittsburgh soccer rivalry returns to US Open Cup

It’s a geographic rivalry that crosses the boundaries of sports. Steelers vs. Eagles, Pirates vs. Phillies, Penguins vs Flyers, Pittsburgh vs. Philadelphia. In the world of American Pro soccer however, the cities have never crossed paths.

  • How a US Open Cup classic, locker room vandalism inspired fans to create Coffee Pot Cup
  • Highs and lows of Los Angeles’ 25 all-time US Open Cup Final appearances
  • Before Lionel Messi’s 2023 US Open Cup impact, Pele changed the 1975 Final in a different way
  • A history of violence against referees in US Open Cup
  • How St. Petersburg Kickers became Florida’s first US Open Cup champion

Analytics powered by

Copyright © 2025 • Built by Jacob Martella Web Development