| Qualifying Round |
| Northwestern New York |
|
|
Rochester Celtic |
4 : 1 |
McNaughton Rangers |
| Massachusetts |
|
|
Clan McLennan |
3 : 2 |
Chicopee Rovers |
10/21/16
|
|
New Bedford Celtic |
4 : 0 |
Lawrence Cricket & FC |
|
|
Swedish American FC |
4 : 1 |
Clan Sutherland |
|
|
Lawrence Olympics |
4 : 1 |
St. George AC |
|
|
Methune FC |
1 : 0 |
Lawrence Thistle |
| Rhode Island |
|
|
Greystone FC |
3 : 2 |
Lonsdale FC |
| Eastern Pennsylvania |
|
|
Veteran AA |
6 : 0 |
Victor Talking Machine Co. |
| Michigan |
|
|
Caledonia FC |
1 : 0 |
Walkerville FC |
|
|
National SFC |
4 : 0 |
Rising Star FC |
| Ohio |
|
|
White Auto |
2 : 1 |
Cuyahoga Works FC |
| Illinois |
|
|
Slavia FC |
3 : 1 |
Wanderers FC |
|
|
|
|
|
| First Round |
| Massachusetts |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Andover United |
4 : 1 |
Clan Sutherland |
| 11/18/16 |
|
New Bedford FC |
2 : 0 |
Pan American FC |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Lawrence Olympic |
5 : 0 |
Methuen FC |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Fall River Rovers |
4 : 0 |
General Electric FC |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Clan McClennan |
4 : 2 |
New Bedford Celtics |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Lynn Hibernians |
2 : 0 |
Fore River Rovers |
| New York & New Jersey |
| 11/12/16 |
|
West Hudson AC |
1 : 0 |
Greenpoint FC |
| 11/19/16 |
|
New York FC |
1 : 0 |
Interborough Rapid Transit FC |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Jersey AC |
4 : 0 |
Irish American FC |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Brooklyn Celtic |
w/o |
Yonkers FC |
| Yonkers FC forfeit due to disbanding |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Clan MacDuff |
0 : 1 |
Bay Ridge FC |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Scottish American FC |
3 : 2 |
Babcock & Wilcox |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Clan MacDonald |
3 : 1 |
Continental FC |
| Northwestern New York |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Rochester City |
w/o |
Rochester Celtic |
| Connecticut |
| 11/12/16 |
|
British American FC |
1 : 0 |
Remington City |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Bridgeport City |
5 : 1 |
Bridgeport Rangers |
| Rhode Island |
| 11/4/16 |
|
Howard & Bullough |
4 : 0 |
Greystone AC |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Crompton FC |
1 : 0 |
J & P Coats |
| Eastern Pennsylvania |
| 11/11/16 |
|
Bethlehem Steel |
5 : 0 |
Veteran AA |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Disston AA |
2 : 0 |
Wanderers FC |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Putnam FC |
3 : 0 |
Allentown YMCA |
| Western Pennsylvania |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Juniata Pennsylvania Railroad FC |
w/o |
Treveskyn FC |
| 11/18/16 |
|
Homestead Steel Works |
1 : 0 |
Braddock Steel |
| Ohio |
| 11/12/16 |
|
White Auto FC |
2 : 1 |
Cleveland FC |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Thistle FC |
4 : 3 |
Akron FC |
| Michigan |
| 11/12/16 |
|
St. George FC |
3 : 1 |
Packard FC |
| 11/15/16 |
|
Detroit FC |
4 : 2 |
National FC |
| Illinois |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Bricklayers FC |
3 : 0 |
Hyde Park Blues |
| 11/19/16 |
|
MacDuff FC |
2 : 0 |
Pullman Professional FC |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Caledonia FC |
3 : 1 |
Roses FC |
| 11/19/16 |
|
Joliet Steel Works |
3 : 1 |
Slavia FC |
| 11/26/16 |
|
Pullman Association FC |
3 : 0 |
Chicago Americans |
|
|
|
|
|
| Second Round |
| 12/16/16 |
|
Andover United |
w/o |
Clan McLennan |
| Clan McLennan forfeit due to suspension of club |
| 12/17/16 |
|
Bridgeport City |
4 : 0 |
British American FC |
| 12/17/16 |
|
Homestead Steel Works |
9 : 2 |
Juniata Pennsylvania Railroad FC |
| 12/17/16 |
|
White Auto FC |
1 : 0 |
Thistle FC |
| 12/17/16 |
|
Rochester City |
0 : 1 |
Detroit FC |
| 12/17/16 |
|
Caledonia FC |
3 : 1 |
St. George FC |
| 12/24/16 |
|
Bricklayers FC |
1 : 2 |
Joliet Steel Works |
| 12/30/16 |
|
Fall River Rovers |
3 : 1 |
New Bedford FC |
| 12/31/16 |
|
West Hudson AC |
2 : 1 |
Clan MacDonald |
| 1/6/17 |
|
Disston AA |
13 : 0 |
Jersey City AC |
| 1/6/17 |
|
Lynn Hibernians |
1 : 0 |
Lawrence Olympics |
| 1/6/17 |
|
Bethlehem Steel |
3 : 1 |
Brooklyn Celtic |
| 1/20/17 |
|
Crompton FC |
0 : 0 |
Howard & Bullough |
| 2/25/17 |
R |
Howard & Bullough |
5 : 2 |
Crompton FC |
| 2/18/17 |
|
Scottish American FC |
2 : 1 |
Bay Ridge FC |
| 3/4/17 |
|
Pullman Association FC |
1 : 3 |
MacDuff FC |
|
|
|
|
|
| Third Round |
| 2/3/17 |
|
Homestead Steel Works |
3 : 1 |
White Auto FC |
| 2/4/17 |
|
Bridgeport City |
0 : 1 |
Disston AA |
| 2/4/17 |
|
West Hudson AA |
0 : 3 |
Bethlehem Steel |
| 2/25/17 |
|
Scottish American FC |
4 : 6 |
New York FC |
| 3/4/17 |
|
Caledonia FC |
2 : 1 |
Detroit FC |
| 3/17/17 |
|
Fall River Rovers |
3 : 1 |
Lynn Hibernains |
| 3/25/17 |
|
Joliet Steel Works |
6 : 0 |
MacDuff FC |
| 3/31/17 |
|
Andover United |
2 : 5 |
Howard & Bullough |
|
|
|
|
|
| Quarterfinals |
| 3/10/17 |
|
Disston AA |
2 : 0 |
New York FC |
| 3/3/17 |
|
Bethlehem Steel |
2 : 1 |
Homestead Steel Works |
| 4/8/17 |
|
Joliet Steel Works |
4 : 0 |
Caledonian FC |
| 4/7/17 |
|
Fall River Rovers |
6 : 1 |
Howard & Bullough |
|
|
|
|
|
| Semifinals |
| 4/21/17 |
|
Fall River Rovers |
4 : 3 |
Disston AA |
| 4/21/17 |
|
Bethlehem Steel |
6 : 0 |
Joliet Steel Works |
|
|
|
|
|
| Final |
|
|
at Coates Field – Pawtucket, Rhode Island |
| 5/5/17 |
|
Fall River Rovers |
1 : 0 |
Bethlehem Steel |
| KEY – w/o – walkover, R – Replay |
