| ROUND 1 | AWAY TEAM | SCORE | HOME TEAM | VENUE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| June 14 | Connecticut Wolves (USISL Pro) | New York Centaurs (A-League) | Downing Stadium – New York, NY | |
| June 14 | Tampa Bay Cyclones (USISL Pro) | 2:4 | Atlanta Ruckus (A-League) | Adams Stadium – Atlanta, GA |
| June 14 | Everett BigFoot (USISL Pro) | 2:9 | Seattle Sounders (A-League) | Lake Washington HS – Kirkland, WA |
| June 14 | Colorado Foxes (A-League) | 6:1 | Flamengo SC (USASA) | Haws Field (BYU) – Provo, UT |
| June 18 | AAC Eagles (USASA) | 1:2 (ASDET) | Chicago Stingers (USISL Pro) | Forest View Park – Arlington Heights, IL |
| June 18 | San Fernando Valley Golden Eagles (USISL Pro) | 0:2 | Chico Rooks (USISL Pro) | Durham HS – Durham, NC |
| June 25 | McCormick Kickers (USASA) | 2:5 | El Paso Patriots (USISL Pro) | Dudley Field, El Paso, TX |
| July 2 | Spartans SC (USASA) | 1:6 | Richmond Kickers (USISL Premier League) | Striker Park – Glen Allen, VA |
| *Richmond defeated Spartans SC 5-2 on June 11, 1995, but Spartans SC filed a protest, claiming that they were not given enough notification for a change in kickoff time, the protest was upheld, and a replay was ordered. They protested again after the replay citing ineligible players but the protest was denied. | ||||
| QUARTERFINALS | AWAY TEAM | SCORE | HOME TEAM | VENUE |
| July 12 | Atlanta Ruckus (A-League) | 1:2 | Richmond Kickers (USISL Premier League) | Univ. of Richmond Stadium – Richmond, VA |
| July 12 | El Paso Patriots (USISL Pro) | 2:0 | Colorado Foxes (A-League) | Sand Creek Stadium – Colorado Springs, CO |
| July 12 | New York Centaurs (A-League) | 0:1 | Chicago Stingers (USISL Pro) | Forest View Park – Arlington Heights, IL |
| July 21 | Chico Rooks (USISL Pro) | 0:5 | Seattle Sounders (A-League) | Juanita High School – Kirkland, WA |
| SEMIFINALS | AWAY TEAM | SCORE | HOME TEAM | VENUE |
| July 30 | Seattle Sounders (A-League) | 0:1 | El Paso Patriots (USISL Pro) | Dudley Field – El Paso, TX |
| August 4 | Chicago Stingers (USISL Pro) | 3:4 | Richmond Kickers (USISL Premier League) | Univ. of Richmond Stadium – Richmond, VA |
| FINAL | AWAY TEAM | SCORE | HOME TEAM | VENUE |
| August 27 | Richmond Kickers (USISL Premier League) | 1:1 (4:2 PK) | El Paso Patriots (USISL Pro) | SISD Student Activities Complex – El Paso, TX |